This posting is inspired from my recent reading of Joy Milne๐ ability and diagnosis of her husband early Parkinson Disease because of his smell.
The science of smell, or olfaction, is a fascinating and complex field that bridges neuroscience, chemistry, biology, and psychology. Here's a concise overview of what scientists know:
๐ฌ How Smell Works (Biological Mechanism)
Odor Detection:
Odor molecules (volatile compounds) enter the nose through the nostrils or the back of the throat.
These molecules bind to olfactory receptors located on olfactory sensory neurons in the olfactory epithelium, a small patch of tissue high inside the nasal cavity.
Signal Transmission:
When an odor molecule binds to a receptor, it triggers an electrical signal.
These signals are sent to the olfactory bulb, a brain structure just above the nasal cavity.
From there, the signal travels to the olfactory cortex and other brain areas like the amygdala (emotion) and hippocampus (memory).
๐ง Why Smell Is So Powerful
Direct Brain Pathway: Unlike other senses, smell has a direct connection to the limbic system (the emotional and memory center), which explains why smells can trigger vivid memories and emotions.
Proustian Effect: Named after Marcel Proust, this refers to how smells evoke deep, autobiographical memories—a whiff of a certain perfume might transport you back decades.
๐งช Chemistry of Smell
Odors are detected based on their molecular shape and structure, but the full mechanism is complex.
The combinatorial code theory says that each smell activates a unique pattern of receptors, like musical notes forming a chord.
Humans have about 400 different types of olfactory receptors, allowing us to distinguish over a trillion different odors, according to some studies.
๐ Variations in Smell Perception
Genetics play a role: Some people can’t smell specific odors (a condition called specific anosmia).
Age affects olfaction: Smell sensitivity typically declines with age.
Culture and experience influence how we interpret and label smells (e.g., a cheese might smell pleasant to one person, repulsive to another).
๐ง ๐งช Recent Discoveries and Applications
Neurodegenerative Disease Diagnosis: Early loss of smell is a symptom of diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s.
Artificial Noses (E-noses): Technology is being developed to mimic human olfaction for use in medicine, food safety, and environmental monitoring.
Fragrance Science: Used in industries ranging from perfume and food to marketing and therapy (like aromatherapy).
Yes, a person’s body odor or the smell of their breath, sweat, urine, or skin can sometimes be a valuable diagnostic clue in medicine. While smell alone is rarely used as the sole diagnostic tool, it can point toward specific conditions, prompting further investigation.
๐ฉบ Medical Conditions That Affect Body Odor or Breath
Here are some examples where a specific smell may suggest a medical issue:
| Smell | Possible Condition |
|---|
| Fruity or sweet breath | Diabetic ketoacidosis (high ketones in diabetics) |
| Ammonia or urine-like breath | Kidney failure (uremic fetor) |
| Musty or mousy odor | Liver failure (especially in severe cases like hepatic encephalopathy) |
| Fishy odor | Trimethylaminuria (genetic disorder also called fish odor syndrome) |
| Rotten or foul-smelling sputum | Lung infections (like anaerobic bacterial infections) |
| Foul vaginal odor | Bacterial vaginosis or Trichomonas infection |
| Burnt or metallic smell in breath | Possible heavy metal poisoning (e.g., arsenic, selenium) |
๐ง Neurological and Rare Disorders
Parkinson’s disease: Some studies suggest that people with Parkinson’s may have a distinctive odor due to changes in skin sebum. A Scottish woman named Joy Milne famously helped scientists identify this possibility by detecting a "musky" scent in patients years before diagnosis.
Phenylketonuria (PKU): A genetic metabolic disorder that can produce a musty odor due to buildup of phenylalanine.
๐งช How Smell Is Used in Diagnosis
Clinician's Nose:
Electronic Noses (E-noses):
Devices are being developed to analyze breath, sweat, or skin gases for chemical markers of disease.
Examples: detecting lung cancer, tuberculosis, COVID-19, and even colorectal cancer from breath or stool odors.
Canines in Medicine:
Trained dogs have shown the ability to detect cancer, hypoglycemia, seizures, and infections through smell with remarkable accuracy.
⚠️ Limitations
Smell can be subjective and influenced by personal perception, medications, diet, or hygiene.
Odor changes may not be specific to one disease.
Smell is better for screening or supporting a diagnosis than providing a definitive one.
A powerful real-world example where smell played a critical diagnostic role involves a woman named Joy Milne, whose extraordinary sense of smell helped researchers detect Parkinson’s disease through body odor.
๐ The Case of Joy Milne and Parkinson’s Disease๐
๐ Background:
Joy Milne, a retired nurse from Scotland, noticed that her husband, Les, had developed a distinct musky odor years before he was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. She later realized that others with Parkinson’s smelled the same way. I have the same experienced with my wife, who suffered of Parkinson Disease for almost 8 years.
๐ฌ Scientific Validation:
Researchers at the University of Manchester took her claims seriously.
They conducted a study where Joy was asked to smell t-shirts worn by people—some with Parkinson’s and some without.
Joy correctly identified all the Parkinson’s patients, but also flagged one person as having the odor even though that person was not diagnosed at the time.
Months later, that individual was diagnosed with Parkinson’s.
๐ What They Found:
Researchers analyzed the sebum (an oily secretion on the skin) from Parkinson’s patients.
They discovered distinct chemical compounds (like hippuric acid, eicosane, and octadecanal) that were elevated in Parkinson’s patients and likely contributed to the odor.
This led to new avenues for non-invasive early detection of the disease via smell.
๐ง Why This Case Is Important
Early Detection: Parkinson’s is often diagnosed after motor symptoms appear, but smell-based detection could help identify it much earlier.
Non-invasive Testing: This case inspired research into developing "electronic noses" to mimic Joy’s ability using chemical sensors.
Human Potential: It highlighted how human olfaction, often overlooked in medicine, can provide meaningful diagnostic clues.
The article in Face Book that inspired my posting above: ๐
She smelled a shift in her husband's scent—long before science could name the change. Joy Milne’s rare gift is not just biological—it’s a reminder of the unseen intelligence woven into our being.
Her story bridges ancient intuition and modern discovery, showing us the power of deep inner awareness. What if our senses are sacred tools for understanding the soul’s messages through the body?
Through her ability, a new path has opened—merging empathy, perception, and science to heal. It speaks to the profound interconnectedness between spirit and matter, heart and health.
Meanwhile, Did you know that.....
In a rare biological role reversal, male seahorses become pregnant. The female deposits eggs into the male’s brood pouch, where he fertilizes and nurtures them. He regulates the environment, provides nutrients, and controls salinity—mimicking a mammalian womb. After weeks of gestation, he goes into labor and gives birth to up to 2,000 tiny seahorses. This unique reproductive strategy is still being studied for its evolutionary benefits. It’s one of nature’s most fascinating parenting systems, challenging traditional ideas of gender roles in biology and offering a rare example of paternal pregnancy.
No comments:
Post a Comment