Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV+, and Starz Highly Rated Shows

I have subscription on three Streaming Services besides my Comcast Account.  

Here are some highly rated and widely recommended TV series you might enjoy with your Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV+, and Starz subscription,  spanning different genres from drama and sci-fi to comedy and adventure: 

Amazon Prime Video

⭐ Critically Acclaimed & Popular

• The Boys – Dark superhero satire with a sharp edge and strong reviews. 

• The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel – Award-winning comedy-drama about a 1950s stand-up comic. 

• Swarm – Psychological dark comedy from Donald Glover that has drawn critical praise. 

👀 Other Well-Rated Prime Shows

Many other Prime Video shows have high critic scores or fan followings, such as: 

• My Lady Jane – historical fantasy drama

• A League of Their Own – sports drama

• The Devil’s Hour – eerie supernatural thriller

• Chloe – psychological mystery

• Batman: Caped Crusader – gritty animated take on Batman

 Apple TV+

🔥 Standouts with Critical Praise

• Severance – Mind-bending workplace thriller with very high critic scores. 

• Pluribus – A new sci-fi series from the creator of Breaking Bad, debuting to excellent early reviews. 

📌 Other Apple TV+ Favorites Worth Trying

Though not all detailed here, other Apple TV+ series often recommended by viewers include (general consensus across fan discussions): 

• Slow Horses – spy drama with stellar ensemble

• Hijack – real-time plane thriller

• Ted Lasso – feel-good comedy (Apple TV classic)

• For All Mankind – alternate history space drama

• Silo – post-apocalyptic mystery adventure

 Starz

Starz has a mix of historical epics, dramas, comedies, and character-driven series, some are classics, others newer highlights: 

🎬 Standouts to Watch

• Outlander – Historical drama blending romance, time travel, and adventure. 

• P-Valley – Gritty character-driven Southern drama with strong acclaim. 

• Howards End – Period miniseries based on E.M. Forster’s novel. 

• Survivor’s Remorse – Comedy-drama with a fresh voice. 

• Da Vinci’s Demons – Imaginative historical fantasy. 

• Party Down – Cult comedy about struggling creatives. 

📺 Other Classics on Starz

Starz has a broader library with fan favorites like Black Sails, Power, The Serpent Queen, and Minx. 

Recommendation Tips

• For dark, high-concept storytelling: Severance (Apple TV+), The Boys (Prime).

• For character-driven dramas: Outlander (Starz), P-Valley (Starz), The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (Prime).

• For something lighter or quirky: Party Down (Starz), Slow Horses (Apple TV+).

  Meanwhile, here 's the Top Rated Shows on Netflix and HBO 
  Netflix's highly rated and most-watched catalog as of early 2026 is dominated by long-running supernatural dramas, fantasy adaptations, and mystery series.
  • Wednesday: The second season of this horror-dramedy is the most-watched show in recent Netflix history, with Season 1 also remaining in the top 10 due to high rewatch rates.
  • Stranger Things: Its final season (Season 5) saw massive viewership following its late 2025 release. All five seasons consistently rank among the most-watched shows on the platform.
  • One Piece: The live-action adaptation of the iconic manga received rare praise from both hardcore fans and general audiences. Season 2 premiered in March 2026.
  • The Night Agent: This action-thriller has remained a staple in the top 10, with Season 3 maintaining high audience scores (82%) on Rotten Tomatoes.
  • Bridgerton: A romance-drama juggernaut, its fourth season continues to draw tens of millions of views.
  • Dark Winds: This mystery-thriller currently holds a 100% fresh critic score on Rotten Tomatoes as of March 2026. 
  Top Rated Shows on HBO (Max)
  HBO continues to lead in prestige dramas and spin-offs of major franchises, with several new entries gaining high critical acclaim in 2026.
  • A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms: This "Game of Thrones" prequel, following Ser Duncan the Tall and his squire Egg, has been a global top-performing series since its January 2026 debut, holding a 94% fresh rating.
  • The Pitt: A realistic medical drama starring Noah Wyle, it is currently one of the most-watched TV shows in the United States on the platform.
  • The Last of Us: Critically acclaimed for its adaptation of the video game, it remains one of HBO's most significant recent hits.
  • Industry: This high-stakes financial drama maintains high ratings (91% fresh) and recently moved into its fourth season in early 2026.
  • The White Lotus: Known for its social satire and shifting ensemble casts, it remains a highly rated staple with a 90% score from audiences.
  • DTF St. Louis: A new dark comedy limited series starring Jason Bateman, David Harbour, and Linda Cardellini that premiered in March 2026 to early positive buzz.